Why is there so much injustice?
09/07/2001
- Opinión
We all feel indignation with the result of the jury verdict that took
place the 18th of June which absolved the landowner who plotted the
murder of the union leader Margarida Alves, in Paraiba in August of
1983. And this is not the only case. Since 1985 more than 1,600
union members, church workers, lawyers, and political representatives
have been murdered in rural areas because of political motives
involving land-related problems. Less than 100 cases have had
processes and judgments. In less than 20, those responsible for the
murders were found guilty. And, by what can be ascertained, only
those involved in three crimes are in prison, those cases which
obviously were very notorious: the murders of Chico Mendes, the priest
Josimo Tavares, and the union leader Canuto. All the rest are
unpunished.
In the case of the police that participated in the massacre of
Carajás, more than five years ago, the assurance of impunity has led
to some of them being implicated in the murder of two other leaders of
the MST, in Paraupebas (PA).
For more than a year now a proposed law has been stalled in the
Senate, after it had been approved in two votes in the House of
Deputies, that would have called for a constitutional amendment, by
the government’s own initiative, to transfer to the Federal Justice
crimes committed against human rights. There is an agreement among
all the political parties for the approval of this project. And, for
some reason which is stronger than the rhetoric of the political
parties and the federal government, the project has not been approved
in the Senate. Why?
The other Brazil
Unfortunately, beyond the absurd physical violence that blinds with
impunity so many lives, in the rural areas there are many more
injustices. Untiringly and courageously the priest Ricardo Resende
continues denouncing the existence of slave labor even today, into the
21st century, in the farms of Sur de Pará. Desperate mothers are
unaware of where their adult children end up, taken by “gatos” (slave
runners) without any word from them. Without documents, without an
address, without citizenship, treated as if they were common
merchandise. Could this be the modern Brazil that Fernando Henrique
Cardoso promised to the Brazilian people seven years ago when he
assumed government power?
We all remain indignant with the stupidity and irresponsibility of the
federal government concerning the electrical energy crisis. But in
the rural areas today there are still millions of Brazilians that are
not familiar with electrical energy. And it is not because they live
in inaccessible caves. We have a school, an installation of MST, that
functions with 600 students, in the old patio of the major
hydroelectric plant of Paraná, Santiago Falls. For the time being, we
are next to the hydroelectric plant. And it has no electricity!
Thousands of farmers in Pará and Maranhao live in the dark, a short
distance from the electric lines of Tucuruí, that carries energy only
for a Canadian multinational company that exports aluminum.
How many more examples could be given of so many injustices, social
violence, and of the existing impunity? There are plenty of examples.
All one needs to do is to walk through this Brazil and observe.
But the key question is: Why do these injustices and impunities
persist? They persist because our society is controlled by a
minority, of the dominant class, of the well-off, who think only in
accumulating wealth, accumulating power. When confronted by
international capital, they are extremely servile. With the Brazilian
people, they are violent and repressors . This minority takes
advantage of the State only in order to guarantee its privileges and
to increase them even more. The Brazilian State has not yet
assimilated the French Revolution of 1789, the separation of the three
powers, and the free and democratic vote. However, more than this,
the Brazilian State is organized, structured, in order to function
only for the benefit of a minority.
As the bishop of Caxias (RJ) Don Mauro Morelli stated recently, “the
Brazilian State is like a van made to accommodate barely ten people.
The populace, crowding into bus stops, has the ability to choose to
change the driver, but only a mere 10% of the people are ever able to
travel in the van.”
Our society needs radical changes, that go to the root of the
problems. And for this it is not enough simply to change the driver.
We need to change the means of transportation so that all Brazilians
can “travel” and not just 10%. Without these changes, the social
injustices will continue increasing and the impunity of the powerful
will continue being part of the rules of the game.
* Joao Pedro Stedile is a member of the National Leadership of the
Movement of Rural Landless Workers (MST).
https://www.alainet.org/en/active/2373
Del mismo autor
- Los dilemas populares en tiempos de crisis del capitalismo 05/11/2021
- Notas sobre as eleições municipais depois do segundo turno 01/12/2020
- Minhas palavras ao ministro Gilmar Mendes 19/08/2020
- Salve o centenário de Florestan Fernandes e Celso Furtado! 16/07/2020
- Medidas de emergência de reforma agrária para enfrentar a crise 05/06/2020
- Em defesa da vida do povo, mudar o governo! 30/04/2020
- Salvar vidas, reorganizar a economia e derrotar Bolsonaro 01/04/2020
- O poder político das empresas de agrotóxicos 02/03/2020
- Um raio-X da oposição direitista da Venezuela 20/01/2020
- Os retrocessos do governo na política agrária, agrícola e ambiental 02/01/2020