Johannesburg junction
19/08/2002
- Opinión
Ten years after the Rio de Janeiro Conference on Environment and Development, the
global environmental situation is unarguably worse. The main culprit: an
unchecked capitalist mode of production that unceasingly transforms nature's
bounty into commodities and incessantly creates new demands. Capitalism
constantly erodes man and woman's being-in-nature (creature) and being-in-society
(citizen) and, even as it drains them of life energy as workers, it moulds their
consciousness around one role: that of consumer. Capitalism has many "laws of
motion," but one of the most destructive as far as the environment goes is Say's
law, which is that supply creates its own demand. Capitalism is a demand-
creating machine that transforms living nature into dead commodities, natural
wealth into dead capital.
Capitalism has expanded unevenly, being now overdeveloped in its heartland in the
North and underdeveloped in the periphery. Thus its environmental impact has
likewise been differentially distributed. Nothing captures this better than the
difference in per capita greenhouse gas emissions: one American emits as much as
17 Maldiveans, 19 Indians, 30 Pakistanis, 49 Sri Lankans, 107 Bangladeshis, 134
Bhutanese, and 269 Nepalis.
The global impact of the superdeveloped capitalist North may, in fact, be greater
than the comparative statistics reveal. For in response to the rise of the
environmental movement, the North has displaced ecological disequilibrium to the
South. Perhaps paradigmatic in this regard is the way Japanese capital has lived
up to environmental standards in the homeland by accelerating its consumption of
nature and creation of waste to East and Southeast Asia. Japanese consumption,
for instance, was responsible for up to 70 per cent of timber logged--most of it
illegally--in the Philippines from the fifties to the nineties. Japanese
consumption of commodities produced from a safe distance drove the uncontrolled
toxification that accompanied the massive transfer of Japan's pollution-intensive
and labor-intensive manufacturing facilities to that region beginning in the late
1960s.
Today, European and US capital have joined Japanese capital in making cheap-
labor, pollution-friendly China both the workshop and the wastebasket of the
world. What is happening to China and East Asia today is, however, only the
latest phase of capitalist globalization's 150-year-old process of displacing the
environmental costs of global capitalist production and consumption from the
center to the subordinate parts of the world economy.
Ten years ago, George Bush Senior torpedoed the Rio Summit by saying "America's
lifestyle is not up for negotiation." The Europeans and the Japanese feigned
horror, but the next ten years showed that consumption was king for them too, and
that ever escalating consumption was the common recipe for keeping the global
capitalist economy going. The Group of Seven has essentially served as a forum to
negotiate which capitalist center would serve at which period as the consumption-
engine of the global economy. The so-called management of the international
economy is essentially a process of determining which center would accelerate its
conversion of nature into commodity and commodity into waste.
Today, the Johannesburg Summit is stillborn, killed over a year before it was held
by George W. Bush's decision to withdraw the world's prime capitalist power from
being party to the Kyoto Climate Change protocol. This is capitalism stripped of
its liberal face, capitalism that reveals its essential nature as an enemy of
nature. The Japanese and European elites pretend to be upset, but what they are
most upset about is the Americans' frank acknowledgment of the basic dynamic of
the system of production they all share: that its continuing expansion must be
achieved via an accelerated consumption and toxification of nature.
Johannesburg will be a mixture of corporate greenwashing, American bullying,
European holier-than-thou posturing, third world leaders begging for aid in return
for more pro-corporate liberalization, and the World Trade Organization hijacking
the environment in the service of free trade. It is one more UN conference bound
for ignominious failure.
This failure comes at a time when Latin America is exploding in rebellion against
neo-liberal economics and lack of accountability and systemic corporate
criminality has eroded the credibility of corporate capitalism in t he United
States, with 72 per cent of Americans feeling that corporations have too much
power over their lives.
It comes at a time when, owing to the crisis of overproduction or overcapacity,
global capitalism's ability to consume its way out of crisis is stymied. The US,
Japan, Europe, and East Asia---the engines of consumption-driven growth--now face
the spectre of a synchronized downspin. What analysts from Marx to Schumpeter have
discerned as self-destructive dynamics of the capitalist system is developing as
nature's revolt becomes more and more evident each day and as consumers
throughout the world are turning into citizens determined to regain community, to
recreate a social solidarity that has been undermined by capitalism.
Johannesburg may well be remembered a significant signpost in the struggle between
capitalism and the environment, capitalism and community. Which side will prevail
remains to be seen.
*Executive Director of Focus on the Global South.
(This article also appears in Red Pepper, September 2002)
FOCUS ON TRADE
NUMBER 80, AUGUST 2002
https://www.alainet.org/en/articulo/109144?language=en
Del mismo autor
- Agrocide in the Philippines and how to stop it 13/08/2021
- Philippine agriculture is dying, what will it take to save it? 10/08/2021
- The Rise and Fall of Multilateralism 14/04/2021
- David slays Goliath in El Salvador 19/03/2021
- Leer a Piketty I: Un resumen conciso y exhaustivo de Capital e Ideología 12/03/2021
- Lecture de Piketty I: Un résumé concis et complet de Capital et idéologie 03/03/2021
- Reading Piketty II: Property, Ideology, and the Mystery of the Missing John Locke 23/02/2021
- Reading Piketty I: A Concise and Comprehensive Summary of Capital and Ideology 19/01/2021
- El asalto al Capitolio indica que EE.UU. ha entrado en la era de Weimar 07/01/2021
- United States: Storming of Capitol shows America has entered the Weimar era 07/01/2021